Stefan Stenudd
Stefan Stenudd
About me
I'm a Swedish writer of fiction and non-fiction books in both Swedish and English. I'm also an artist, a historian of ideas and an aikido instructor.



Psychoanalysis of Myth

Introduction

Sigmund Freud

Totem and Taboo

Moses and Monotheism

Carl G. Jung

Archetypes

Collective unconscious

Applying Jung to myth

Personal myth


MYTH

Creation Myths:
An Introduction

Psychoanalysis of Myth

Creation Myths Around the World

The Logics of Myth

Genesis 1: The First Creation of the Bible

Enuma Elish: Babylonian Creation

Ideas and Learning


THE GREEK PHILOSOPHERS

ARISTOTLE

Aristotle - Life and Work

Aristotle's Poetics

Aristotle's Cosmology


Cosmos of the Ancients, by Stefan Stenudd.

Cosmos of the Ancients
The Greek philosophers and what they thought about cosmology, myth, and the gods, by Stefan Stenudd. Click the image to see the book at Amazon.


Life Energy Encyclopedia, by Stefan Stenudd.
Life Energy Encyclopedia
by Stefan Stenudd. Qi, prana, spirit, and other life forces around the world explained and compared. Click the image to see the book at Amazon.


Tao Te Ching - The Taoism of Lao Tzu Explained, by Stefan Stenudd.
Tao Te Ching
The Taoism of Lao Tzu Explained. The great Chinese classic, translated and extensively commented by Stefan Stenudd. Click the image to see the book at Amazon.


Tarot Unfolded, by Stefan Stenudd.
Tarot Unfolded
This book presents an imaginative reading of the Tarot divination cards, which is the most appropriate for the Tarot since it consists of symbolic images. Click the image to see the book at Amazon.





Stenudd's Blog





Psychoanalysis of Myth 5

Sigmund Freud's and C. G. Jung's Theories on Myth and Its Origin.

Psychoanalysis of Myth: Freud and Jung.

Carl G. Jung

Carl Gustav Jung was born in Switzerland in 1875, the son of a priest who died when he was 21. He studied medicine in Basel until 1900, his interest in psychiatry awakened by the end of his studies, and later worked at a psychiatric hospital in Zürich. In 1902 he got his MD with the dissertation On the Psychology and Pathology of So-Called Occult Phenomena. Between 1905 and 1913 he was a lecturer of psychiatry at the University of Zürich. In 1909 he opened a private practice, which he would run until his death.




Carl G. Jung
Carl G. Jung.


     He sent his 1906 book The Psychology of Dementia Praecox (the ailment later by Eugen Bleuler renamed schizophrenia) to Sigmund Freud, which started a collegial friendship between them. This was turned into dispute and separation, especially with Jung's 1912 publication Neue Bahnen der Psychologie, questioning Freud's focus on sexual trauma and the Oedipus complex. Jung's first mention of the term archetype was in the 1919 text Instinct and the Unconscious. In 1921 he published Psychological Types, and in 1941 together with Karl Kerényi Essays on a Science of Mythology. He died in 1961.

     Jung's writing on myth is not to be found concentrated to one or a few books on this subject, as is the case with Freud, but quite sprayed all over his works. There is rarely a text of his that does not touch on the subject, and just as rarely one devoted exclusively to it. So, Jung's theories on myth come to us in bits and pieces, spread over all his writing. The job of systematizing has mainly been left in the hands of his pupils and followers. Among them, though, it is almost equally difficult to find one with the intention to bring together and present Jung's theories on myth in any authoritative and organized fashion. So, his gospel is an elusive one, presenting few straightforward answers, which rhymes quite well with his world view.


Influence

Jung's ideas on myth and religion have made far more of an impact than those of Freud - among scholars, as well as to an even larger extent on the general public. Where Freud remains little more than a joke in the field of history of religion and the study of myth, Jung has made a lasting impression through most of the 20th century, to seemingly fade only in the last decade or so.

     Apart from his own widely read writing, which deals considerably with myths, mythology and many elements of religion, he has greatly influenced a number of significant scholars and writers on these themes. The most important of them are Mircea Eliade (1907-86) and Joseph Campbell (1904-76). The former has written many books on myths and how they should be interpreted, and he also formed the minds of numerous students as head of the University of Chicago History of Religion department for almost 30 years. The latter's books have become bestsellers and made deep impressions on the general public, as to how myth should be regarded. He was also the central participant in a 1987 TV series about mythology, which received a huge audience in many countries.

     In addition, there is also the continued work of Jungian theorists and psychologists, more often than not involving their perspective on myth in their writing on the mind of man and the inner workings of society. Notable Jungian theorists dealing extensively with myth are Erich Neumann (1905-1960), Marie-Louise von Franz (1915-1998), and James Hillman (1926-).

     By the sheer mass of it, Jungian literature on myth has set a standard and its theories have become a paradigm of sorts, as to how myths should be interpreted. In addition, Jungian perspectives have influenced how first source material is recorded and presented. During the second half of the 20th century, some myths and lore were documented through Jungian viewpoint, whether or not that was adequate for the material. Future analysis of such records will need to filter off the Jungian tendencies, if they want to apply other theses to them, much like the Christian viewpoint needs to be washed off myths collected by missionaries in the 19th century. It may prove to be quite a challenge.


Opposing Freud

Sigmund Freud. Where Freud was mainly interested in the origin of religion and explanations to ritual, Jung focused on myth and legend, the stories told within religions. To him, these stories were the essence of any religion, and therefore he was more keen to explore the origin of myths, than of religion as a whole.

     Also contrary to Freud, Jung saw myth and its meaning within the individual psyche. In spite of myths and their components being shared by all members of a society - and essentially by all mankind - their workings are strictly personal. According to Jung, man is on a quest towards self-realization, and myths serve as clues to this process. Although every person has this quest, fulfilling it in various degrees, it is a solo venture, each man for himself. This difference between Freud and Jung can be compared to the generalizations of hinayana and mahayana in Buddhism. The former is to find one's way to spiritual perfection in solitude, the latter as a joint effort together with people of the same conviction. Freud saw the individual as deeply dependent on society and anxious to conform to it, while Jung saw society as little more than a number of individuals of similar nature.

     Therefore, to Jung the myths contain messages to the individuals, not the group, no matter how many people are involved in retelling and listening to them. Myths speak to each individual in the same way, but have to be dealt with individually.

     Jung himself pointed out other differences to Freud, mainly those in how to interpret dreams and fantasies:


I did not reduce them to personal factors, as Freud does, but - and this seemed indicated by their very nature - I compared them with the symbols from mythology and the history of religion, in order to discover the meaning they were trying to express.

     Jung also objected to the sexual themes Freud mostly found in dream interpretation:


Whereas he will always look for sexual causes, I trace the origin of dreams back to age-old mythological influences. Deriving from our remotest ancestors, there slumber in all of us subconscious memories which awaken at night and seek to compensate the false attitude modern man has towards nature.

     The above quotes demonstrate what utter importance Jung put on myths. To him they were little less than manifestations of a world premise from the dawn of man, comparable to Fiat!, the divine 'Let there be!' by which the god of the Bible created the world.


Myth as self-realization

To Jung, myths emerged from the unconscious and contained archaic truth about existence: "Myths are first and foremost psychic phenomena that reveal the nature of the soul."


Ancestor figure, from Bakota, Gabon.
Ancestor figure, from Bakota, Gabon.


     Although Jung emphasized the myths as stories, a series of related events from a beginning to an end, he showed no interest in the satisfaction of relief that Aristotle called catharsis, a mental or emotional cleansing appearing in the audience of a good drama. Jung also pointed out the emotional attraction of those stories, but explained it as a resonance from within the human mind, an inner recognition of the hidden truth those stories contained. In that way, the myths served as inspiration. The hidden truth was a number of keys of how to find self-realization, and the inspiration was one of getting people started on that path.


Myth is the primordial language natural to these psychic processes, and no intellectual formulation comes anywhere near the richness and expressiveness of mythical imagery.

     The most obvious example is that of the hero myth, where the hero's struggle to overcome his fear and other obstacles to reach his goal, serves as an instigation for every person to do the same - get free of inhibition, and find the courage to pursue the path that leads to the realization of one's own potential. The myth is a kind of self-therapeutic manual, and the final outcome for the successful user of it is an enlightened mind, someone who truly knows himself.

     This self-realization Jung calls the individuation process. It mainly consists of joining the unconscious with the conscious, by having the knowledge of the former rise to the latter. When man is completely aware of his subconscious and what is stored therein, he has reached self-realization and truly knows himself.


Psychoanalysis
of Myth

  1. Introduction
  2. Sigmund Freud
  3. Totem and Taboo
  4. Moses and Monotheism
  5. Carl G. Jung
  6. Archetypes
  7. Collective unconscious
  8. Applying Jung to myth
  9. Personal myth
This article was originally written in 2006 for a seminar at the Department of History of Ideas, Lund University, as a part of my dissertation in progress on Creation Myths and their patterns of thought. Transforming the text to webpages, I have excluded footnotes. Published on this website September 10, 2007.


© Stefan Stenudd 2006